Seventeen's Joshua has been in the biggest spotlight since his debut - unfortunately this attention and focus is not a positive issue, but a resentful baptism of fans who have been Jasin's biggest supporters with romance rumours. Although the romance rumor has been a critical factor for the idol group members in the past, in modern society, the culture of respecting diversity and individual free choice has been emphasized, and the attitude of accepting the romance rumor of the idol has become more and more tolerated. Fans have also become more inclined to respect their privacy, as idol groups disclose their devotion and directly disclose information about their devotion. Recently, Black Pink's index has been congratulated by Global Fandom in recognition of actor Ahn Bo-hyun and devotees. However, Seventeen's Joshua's romance rumor was firmly horny, with fans unusually demanding withdrawal. Why is Joshua so heavily saturated with fans? Joshua's romance rumor spread around SNS and community. Suspicions have been raised that influencer A, who is believed to be Joshua and GFriend, matched their SNS profile photos with their childhood photos, and clothes, cell phone cases, and accessories that the two suspect as couple items have been found continuously in A's posts since then. In addition, A was found attending Seventeen's concert held in July.The performance and seats were so competitive that even fans couldn't go, so fans were disappointed to see A enjoying the concert at the invitation seat. Even this was taken on an online concert video sold for a fee. Joshua was a member who did not have much communication with Fandom compared to other members. This year, he did not live on the communication platform Weverse, and the number of posts was small enough to reach his hand. It was Instagram that communicated with fans instead of Weavers, and if the romance rumor is true, it means that they were using it as a rub stargram with GFriend. As a result of matching the pieces of the puzzle, both Joshua and A did not show any willingness to hide their devotion, so the fans are furious that Joshua deceived the Jasin. Since the agency Pledis has been raised in the romance rumor, it has become a matter of dividing Fandom and raising anger. As mentioned earlier, with the attitude of fans accepting romance rumors and respecting the privacy of individual members, agencies have become a trend to respond to romance rumors with their agency's "Irreplaceable You" or silent response, Pledis also adhered to this line. However, Pledis overlooked the fact that "Irreplaceable You" and "Irreplaceable You" can be taken only when it is limited to members who do not have a big impact on their relationship with their fans, . In fact, Pledis and Joshua are currently in a position to make an official position and to suppress the situation. Even if you want to apologize to your fans for their neglected behavior, it is burdensome to mention the romance rumor. Apart from the factual relationship, they are ordinary people, not celebrities, even though they are influencers. For them, the most realistic alternative may be to hope that the controversy will subside quickly over time. Fandom, too, is aware of and wary of that. Seventeen's Fandom, who does not want to step down easily, is constantly referring to Joshua's GFriend issue on Twitter real-time trends, and China Fandom is protesting by sending a truck to Joshua to leave the hive. Idol and Fandom have a strong emotional connection through the group's music and activities, and this Joshua incident has become an example of the fact that the silence in the romance rumor or attitude that can interfere with it becomes a backlash. Unfortunately, while it is consistent with non-compliance, excessive speculation and indiscriminate criticism will also increase, which will signal the erosion of trust between artists, agencies, and Fandom.